Leading Volunteers as a Volunteer: Tips for Effective Leadership

The Reality of Volunteer Leadership

Most volunteer leaders are wearing multiple hats. You might be a parent, employee, caregiver, scheduler, recruiter, and conflict-resolver all at once. Few people receive formal volunteer management training before stepping into these roles, which can lead to feeling overwhelmed, underprepared, and isolated.

The challenge isn't a lack of commitment. It's a lack of structure, clarity, and support.

Finding Volunteers and Building a Team That Lasts

One of the biggest misconceptions about volunteer recruitment is that it's about begging people to help. It's not.

People volunteer for meaning, not just need. Effective volunteer recruitment strategies focus on connection and purpose rather than desperation.

Instead of saying, "We need help," be specific:

• "We need someone to manage the spring schedule."
• "We're looking for someone organized to handle tournament planning."
• "Our social media presence needs help. Who has experience in this area?"

Leading Volunteers (Without Being Perfect)

Volunteer leadership is built on clarity, communication, and appreciation. Set expectations early: who is responsible for what, how decisions are made, and how information flows. One of the most common breakdowns in volunteer organizations is communication: what's discussed in the meeting room doesn't always reach the people at the field.

Create simple, consistent ways to share updates. Invite feedback. Explain decisions when possible. Volunteers don't expect perfection but they do need transparency.

Mistakes will happen. Learn from them, adjust, and move forward. Modeling flexibility and accountability builds trust far faster than trying to do everything "right."

Avoiding Burnout by Leading with Balance

Burnout is one of the biggest threats to volunteer sustainability, especially for leaders.

Build a leadership circle instead of carrying everything yourself. Delegate responsibility, trust your team, and spread the workload. Volunteers have jobs, families, and full lives—expectations should reflect that reality.

When volunteer leaders burn out, organizations lose far more than a role. They lose experience, continuity, and institutional knowledge.

Celebrating the Power of Volunteers

The heart of volunteer-driven organizations isn't a scoreboard, a report, or a metric—it's people.

That's the power of volunteers. And that's why learning how to lead them, even when you're one too, is worth the effort.